World

England v India: third men’s cricket Test, day five – live

Key events

“There appears to be much hand-wringing about this England side’s approach to cricket,” writes Ben Heywood, “a consensus being that they continue to throw away good positions with silly shots. I think this is indisputably true, but most England sides of the past wouldn’t have pulled off a run chase like Headingley in the first place, so I can take the rough with the smooth. What many casual observers seem to be forgetting, however, is that this India side are no 1 in the rankings – it’s no disgrace to go down fighting to what is, on this evidence, a very, very strong line-up that has an all-time God in its bowling ranks. England, in contrast, have a flaky opener, a flaky no 3 and a collection of semi-permanently injured fast-bowlers currently missing their brightest new breakthrough act and their previously most successful seamer (albeit for very different reasons). We also do not have an experienced front-line spinner. I suspect that we, the gen pop, haven’t quite given this India side their due. If the opposition were Australian, expectations would be tempered accordingly. India by four wickets for me, but if Jofra and Brydon can bowl fast, straight and nasty in the first hour, who knows…?”

All batters throw away good positions with silly shots – often the same silly shots that got them into that good position in the first place. I think it’s fair to say England needed to modify their approach a little and I’m glad they have, but I don’t expect the change to be uniform and immediate, nor would I necessarily blame a defeat today on the way they play. Ultimately, though all their bowlers are useful, none are able to run through a side, so taking 20 wickets will always be a performance.

Share

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *